Skip to content
-
Subscribe to our newsletter & never miss our best posts. Subscribe Now!
Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED) Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED)

Andrei Eugen Drăguț - Understand the Patterns. Question the Narratives. Follow the Evidence. Act with Clarity.

Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED) Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED)

Andrei Eugen Drăguț - Understand the Patterns. Question the Narratives. Follow the Evidence. Act with Clarity.

  • Home
  • Interviews
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Editorial Principles
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Interviews
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Editorial Principles
  • Contact
Close

Search

  • https://www.facebook.com/
  • https://twitter.com/
  • https://t.me/
  • https://www.instagram.com/
  • https://youtube.com/
Subscribe
Home/Evidence/Black holes of every size appear to launch jets at the same two percent of Eddington
Andrei Eugen Drăguț
EvidenceMethodsTechnology

Black holes of every size appear to launch jets at the same two percent of Eddington

Unknown's avatar
By Andrei Eugen Drăguț
19/09/2026 3 Min Read
0

A new work in Nature Astronomy that pins down when supermassive black holes “burp” — the moment they fire jets after tearing a star apart. Dr Adelle Goodwin of Curtin University and Dr Andrew Mummery of the Institute for Advanced Study studied twenty tidal disruption events with radio telescopes and found two distinct outflow phases. The first arrives while the black hole feeds at very high, super-Eddington rates. The second arrives hundreds to thousands of days later, when the feeding rate falls to about 2% of the Eddington limit — the same critical threshold long observed in stellar-mass black holes roughly ten to fifty times the Sun’s mass. The Nature Astronomy abstract states the critical rate as Lcrit ≈ 0.02 LEdd and argues the agreement across vastly different mass scales points to a single, scale-invariant jet-launching process.

Andrei Eugen Drăguț

What a tidal disruption event lets you watch

Supermassive black holes in ordinary active galaxies evolve on millennia-long clocks; watching one cross a jet-launch threshold in real time is normally impossible. A star shredded near a supermassive black hole — a tidal disruption event — compresses that evolution into years. Goodwin told The Guardian that only about half the disrupted star is eventually swallowed; the rest can be launched outward in jets and outflows large enough to shape a galaxy’s evolution. Radio, she said, is the band where those outflows can be tracked as they move. Timing had been the mystery: sometimes the “burp” came a year after the star’s destruction, sometimes three or five. The new work ties that scatter to the accretion cycle rather than to random delays. Certain on the Nature Astronomy abstract for “A universal critical accretion rate for black hole jet formation”: twenty TDEs studied; two outflow phases; delayed outflow near ≈0.02 LEdd; match to stellar-mass state-transition thresholds; claim of scale-invariant accretion–outflow coupling; predictive framework for which black holes launch jets and when. Assumed — and not concluded here — is that every future TDE will obey the same calendar, or that jet power is independent of black-hole spin and magnetic geometry beyond what the paper tests.

Messy eaters and galaxy-scale consequences

Goodwin’s phrase, reported by The Guardian, is that black holes are “actually very messy eaters.” Matter must get extremely close before the event horizon wins; stars are destroyed farther out, in the tidal field. The half of the star that is not swallowed can leave as jets capable of influencing a galaxy’s evolution — the “burp” in the popular framing. The scientific payload is not the metaphor. It is the demonstration, via radio monitoring of twenty TDEs, that the delayed outflow aligns with a critical accretion rate already known from stellar-mass systems. The abstract’s claim that a single physical process governs jet launching across mass scales is the peer-reviewed centre of gravity.

Why the number matters for observers

Goodwin said the result should let astronomers predict launch windows more tightly and spend scarce telescope time with less guesswork. Independent astrophysicist Dr Sara Webb of Swinburne, quoted by The Guardian and not on the paper, said the study shows supermassive black holes behave rather predictably at two distant periods in their evolution and ties that behaviour back to the smaller stellar-mass systems. The Nature Astronomy abstract adds that the work naturally explains prompt and delayed outflows seen in TDEs and their detection rates. Hypothesis that holds on these sources: a shared critical accretion rate is now measured across the mass ladder for jet launching. Conclusion that does not hold: that the “burp” metaphor replaces the physics, or that event-horizon folklore is what the paper measured. What was measured is radio-tracked outflow timing against accretion-rate thresholds.

Sources: nature.com

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Tags:

black holesEddingtonGoodwinjetsMummeryNature Astronomyscale invariancetidal disruption events
Unknown's avatar
Author

Andrei Eugen Drăguț

Follow Me
Other Articles
Two pale sculpted hands emerge from a dark wall, palms open and empty above a loaf of bread on a wooden shelf.
Previous

God does not need You

Andrei Eugen Drăguț
Next

Mercury may have shrunk by up to twenty-three kilometres once rough terrain stops hiding the wrinkles

No Comment! Be the first one.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Copyright 2026 — Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED). All rights reserved.
%d