Skip to content
-
Subscribe to our newsletter & never miss our best posts. Subscribe Now!
Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED) Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED)

Andrei Eugen Drăguț - Understand the Patterns. Question the Narratives. Follow the Evidence. Act with Clarity.

Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED) Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED)

Andrei Eugen Drăguț - Understand the Patterns. Question the Narratives. Follow the Evidence. Act with Clarity.

  • Home
  • Interviews
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Editorial Principles
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Interviews
  • Privacy Policy
  • About
  • Editorial Principles
  • Contact
Close

Search

  • https://www.facebook.com/
  • https://twitter.com/
  • https://t.me/
  • https://www.instagram.com/
  • https://youtube.com/
Subscribe
Home/Society/Collective Behavior/God, the human being, the collective, biology, death, and the web of meaning
A quiet study at dusk: an open book, a fountain pen, and a vase of flowers on a wooden desk beneath a well-made window. Through the glass a city and a distant sun. On the plaster wall at left, a backlit coat of arms hangs as a small relief.
Collective BehaviorCritical ThinkingCultureEssaysEvidenceLearningMeaningMethodsMindPsychologyPurposeReflectionsRelationshipsSelf-KnowledgeSocietySpiritualityWisdom

God, the human being, the collective, biology, death, and the web of meaning

Unknown's avatar
By Andrei Eugen Drăguț
25/09/2026 33 Min Read
0

What we call “God” can first be read as existence and life passed through the filter of subjectivity, culture, temperament, need, fear, and psychic mechanisms. Projection, idealization, attachment, the need for meaning, and the fear of death are not surface accidents. They are the operations by which a reflexive organism turns the world into significance. This is the line of Feuerbach, Freud, Marx, and a large part of the psychology of religion, and it explains, without leftover mystery, why images of God vary so widely from one age to another, from one culture to another, and from one temperament to another. The same fact can also be read otherwise. The psychic filter does not prove that God does not exist. It proves only that we have no access to God outside the filter. Love, the self, and the world are likewise mediated psychically and culturally, and it does not follow that they are merely projections. The fact that “God” appears through subjectivity does not automatically mean that “God” is only subjectivity. Mediation describes access. It does not exhaust the object of access.

A quiet study at dusk: an open book, a fountain pen, and a vase of flowers on a wooden desk beneath a well-made window. Through the glass a city and a distant sun. On the plaster wall at left, a backlit coat of arms hangs as a small relief.

If by God one means Existence itself or Life itself, the most coherent wording is not that God is simply filtered existence, but that Existence and Life appear and are perceived in a human way through the filter of subjectivity. Subjectivity does not stand outside Existence. It is a form of it. God is not the filter. God is the Real given to us only as filtered. Along this line, positions open that should not be confused with one another, even though they answer the same question. Spinoza’s pantheism identifies God with Nature and says that everything is in God. Panentheism keeps the world in God, yet leaves God exceeding the world. Tillich refuses to make God a being among beings and names God the ground of being. Jung reads God as an archetype of the Self, an autonomous psychic reality rather than a mere conscious projection. Apophatic mysticism does not name. It points by silence and negation. Humanist atheism sees in God only the projection of the need for meaning and protection. The variety of these answers does not cancel the shared fact: all of them speak of a horizon that no longer refers onward, and all of them speak of it from inside a filter.

Why there is no percentage

The wording that identifies God with the filter remains a fertile half-truth. Its truth is that every experience of God is inevitably filtered psychically, linguistically, and culturally. The missing half is that the filter does not exhaust the question whether a referent exists beyond it. One may fairly say that God-for-us is existence and life lived through subjectivity. One cannot pass, without a further argument, from the fact that God is experienced through the psyche to the conclusion that God is only psyche. If God is Existence or Life, God is not filtered in Godself. God appears filtered to us. The question “what is God?” remains bound to the question “what is the human being?”

The precise question is therefore not whether God is the filter, but how much is psychic representation and how much is a referent beyond representation. A percentage cannot be given, and not for lack of data. The question mixes two planes. Representation and referent are not two layers in the same object, like butter and jam on a slice of bread. Representation is our mode of access. The referent is what might exist beyond access. To measure how much of “God” is representation and how much is referent, one would have to compare the representation with the referent independently, yet every comparison is still made through representation. There is no Archimedean point from which the referent could be seen bare. The demand for a percentage is not a demand for precision. It is a confusion of kinds.

As a human phenomenon, every God we meet in experience, thought, prayer, theology, mysticism, or culture is wholly mediated by subjectivity, language, brain, culture, and personal history. There is no raw God at our disposal. Even revelation, if it exists, is received through human filters. The psychology of religion can explain projection, attachment, the need for meaning, fear of death, agency detection, theory of mind, idealization, trauma, and mystical experience. Explaining how a representation arises does not decide whether a referent exists. Every perception has a neural correlate, and that does not make it automatically illusory. The origin of an image and the truth of an image are different questions.

If a referent exists beyond representation, it is not a component of the representation and not the remainder left after the filter is subtracted. It is either the possible cause of the representation, or nothing. From inside the representation one cannot decide between zero and non-zero. Constructivism and atheism say the representation has no transcendent referent. Theistic realism says the referent exists, but is always filtered, and the representation may be a trace rather than a capture. Agnosticism says the data fit both. The same psychological facts — that brain and culture build representations — can be read as “filter,” which already posits a referent that is filtered, or as “construct,” which already posits that the referent does not exist or does not matter causally. Mediation proves neither existence nor non-existence. The word “filtered” is already a metaphysics. The word “constructed” is another metaphysics. The data stay the same.

A photograph of a mountain is entirely paper, pixels, angle, camera, and visual culture. The mountain is not a fraction of the photograph. If the mountain exists, it is not a piece of the image. It is what the image points to. If it does not exist, the photograph is construction from end to end. From the photograph alone one cannot decide. That is why, as a human phenomenon, God is wholly representation, mediation, and construction. As referent, God cannot be measured in percentages, and remains either zero or non-zero. We know that every image of God is filtered. We do not know, by the same methods, whether the filter has a referent beyond it. God-for-us is wholly representation. God-in-Godself remains either nonexistent or beyond representation, and that is not settled by psychology, but by faith, metaphysical argument, or agnostic suspension.

What theistic realism adds without cancelling the discipline

This discipline is prolonged, not cancelled, when a theistic realism of the Actus Purus kind enters. The confirmation remains phenomenological. Every God we have is mediated. There is no Archimedean point. The alternative between “filtered” and “constructed” is already metaphysical. The question “how much?” is wrong as a proportion. The correction is metaphysical and ethical. If you choose the referent, you may not make it dependent on representation. A God without potency, without need, and without completion does not come to know, feed, or actualize Godself through the human filter. When the filter becomes food, the slide bears Hegel’s name: the Absolute completes itself in history and needs our recognition in order to be what it is.

Experience can be read in three classes, and none of them measures the source. The first class is the phenomenon itself: life, brain, culture, regularity. The second is the reading of the same phenomenon as alignment or recognition. The third claims an effect that exceeds the subject’s ordinary powers, without the source receiving an hour on the clock. The referent is not the remainder after the filter is subtracted. It is either the possible cause of the series, or nothing. Methodological agnosticism is respected by this sorting. Theistic realism goes beyond it as an assumed decision, not as a demonstration from data.

On the same discipline several roads that seemed open fall away. Pantheism cancels the contingency of the world if God is Nature, because the world might not have been. Jung draws the detector too near the source if the archetype of the Self is almost identical with what it is supposed to detect. Tillich comes close, yet the ground of being remains too abstract beside a face, a name, and a dated body. The apophatic must be kept as a limit, not as a shelter that rewrites the wound in order to protect the referent’s honor. Panentheism is the nearest label and still the wrong one wherever God is affected, enriched, and incomplete without the world. The minimal scheme remains this: God-for-us is wholly representation; God-in-Godself is either nonexistent or beyond. If you affirm the referent, the prohibition is not to turn it into a consumer of the filter.

The filter is not only psychic

The filter itself is not a pure interior. Social introspection shows that thoughts, emotions, and beliefs are shaped by internalized norms, roles, relations of power, belongings, privileges, and disadvantages. The image of God is not only a projection of psychic needs. It is a social representation that can reproduce paternal authority, hierarchy, fear of exclusion, the legitimation of power, or the communal ideal. Family, school, church, class, gender, ethnicity, nation, and history do not stand around the subject as scenery. They are taken inward as voice, shame, loyalty, and the right to speak. God-for-us is wholly mediated, including socially. God-in-Godself is not decided by social introspection. The legitimate question of that introspection is another: what in the representation is the product of my social place, of power, of the fear of losing belonging.

The layers can be distinguished without being split. There is an individual psychic layer, a social-relational layer, an institutional-political layer, and a cultural-historical layer. All of them can be examined. None of them exhausts the referent, and none of them proves its nonexistence. They show how thick the filter is. Here a special risk appears: social idolatry. God can become the legitimation of the nation, defender of the ruling class, guarantor of patriarchy, instrument of group control, identity mark against the other. The question that unmasks these faces is simple and hard to bear: who benefits. A God who needs our power, our recognition, and common enemies is no longer Actus Purus, but an idol that feeds on the social filter. Social introspection can clean the representation. It cannot close the metaphysical question. The move from “this image is socially built” to “God does not exist” remains a leap, not a deduction.

Eight relations held on two planes

The relations among God, the human being, the collective, and biology must be held on two planes, or they blur. Phenomenologically we speak of what we live and represent. Ontologically, if a stance is assumed, we speak of what the referent might be if one chooses, for instance, a theistic realism with Actus Purus. There is no neutral answer that satisfies both planes at once. There is a coherent scheme that keeps them apart.

For the human being, God is the last horizon of meaning, the limit, the ground, or the vacancy that remains after intramundane explanations run out, and access is only to mediated representations. Ontologically, God is not an amplified human and not a being among beings. The human being is contingent, composite, temporal, mortal. If God exists as Actus Purus, God is unconditioned, without potency, without need, without completion. The relation is not that God needs the human being, but that the human being is held in being. The human being does not feed God, and God is not actualized through the human being. Phenomenologically, the human being is the one who asks the question and who can refuse, love, idolize, keep silent, pray, or blaspheme. The human being is the subject of representation. Ontologically, the human being is a finite creature, possibly imago Dei, not a fragment of God, not an organ of the Absolute, limitedly free and mortal. Relation is possible. Relation does not make God dependent.

The great religions belong to communities, and the collective mediates language, rite, morals, and image. That is precisely why “our God” can become a social idol, a legitimation of power, war, privilege, and hatred of the other. Ontologically, God is not the property of the community and cannot be captured by a people, a church, a party, or a class. The community may be witness, mediator, place of revelation, not owner. If God needs collective recognition in order to be God, God is no longer God.

The human being is a junction of relations. The self is formed socially through language, roles, norms, recognition, and belonging, and the collective is taken inward as voice, shame, loyalty, and aspiration. The human being is not reduced to roles. There is inwardness, conscience, the capacity to refuse, and responsibility. The human being is at once a product of the collective and a possible critic of it. The collective can enlarge good and evil, can offer meaning or devour the person. It is itself an emergent reality: language, institutions, economy, religion, tradition, power. It is transpersonal, yet dependent on individuals. It has no unified moral consciousness of the personal kind. It can have a group mind, but fragmented, contradictory, manipulable. It forms and constrains, gives identity, and can idolize nation, party, church, corporation, or tribe. When the collective becomes absolute, the human being becomes a tool.

The collective produces representations of God after its own likeness: a warrior God, a God of order, a God of the ruling class, a God of the victims. Ontologically the collective is created and held, as the human being is. It is not saved by number, power, institution, or critical mass. The church is not God. The chosen people are not God. The collective may be witness, not master, and cannot bargain with God by the mere fact of existing as a collective.

The human being is biological: organism, evolution, brain, hormones, genes, death. Biology is the condition of possibility for mind, culture, morals, and religion. We are not spirits fallen into a machine. We are biology that has become reflexive. Culture, language, symbol, norms, art, and metaphysics are real emergences with a biological base. Biology constrains. It does not determine completely. The human being is an animal that asks whether it is only an animal. The collective rests on social biology — cooperation, empathy, status, aggression, reproduction, attachment, betrayal detection. Without these capacities there would be no family, tribe, state, market, or church. It also has cultural emergence: language, institutions, religion, economy, law, cultural replicators. It has no single genome. It is fragile, dependent on bodies and shared beliefs.

The epistemic order runs from biology to the human being, from the human being to the collective, from the collective to the representation of God. If the referent exists beyond the filter, the ontological order may run the other way: God, then biology, the human being, the collective. Confusion appears when we take the order of our knowing for the order of being and treat the social representation of God as God. Then the collective idol becomes absolute.

The cascade of mediation

Representation is not the act of a pure subject. It is a cascade of levels with partial autonomy and partial dependence. The biological level supplies the raw material: brain, nervous system, basic emotions, attachment, fear of death, agency detection. The psychic level turns this material into experience: self, memory, imagination, projection, idealization, trauma. The social level shares and validates it through language, roles, norms, power, and recognition. The cultural level makes it a system: symbol, myth, rite, theology, institution. The metaphysical level is the place where representation recognizes itself as representation and asks about the referent. The interaction is not linear. Each level constrains and permits the next. Biology does not determine culture, but it limits it. Culture does not determine biology, but it shapes it. The psyche does not determine the social, but it filters it. The social does not determine the psyche, but it forms it. God-for-us is the crossing of these levels, not a single stratum. It is neither purely biological, nor purely social, nor purely metaphysical.

Meaning works hierarchically. Every finite meaning points onward. Why do I work? For the family. Why family? For love. Why love? Because we are relational beings. Why relational? Because that is the human condition. Why the human condition? The chain either stops in a brute fact, or runs on forever, or stops at a horizon that no longer points onward. That horizon is called God in a religious register, the Absolute, the Real, or the Ground in a philosophical register. It is not an empirical conclusion. It is a transcendental structure: the limit of the series, not the largest item in it. The function of last horizon is unavoidable in any system of meaning. Whether a referent exists beyond the function remains open.

The subject is stratified as well. There is the organism that produces pre-conscious representations. There is the reflexive self that feels, believes, and prays. There is the person in roles, the group member, the bearer of norms. There is the collective as an emergent producer of shared representations, contested as a subject, real as an effect. There is the transcendental subject as the condition of possibility of any experience, not as one more empirical I. None of them is last. Each is a junction in a web. The subject is not a substance. It is a process.

Junctions of relation are at once wholes relative to their parts and parts relative to larger wholes. From neuron to brain, from organism to person, from pair to group, from institution to society, from humanity to the biosphere, each level has its own causality, is constrained from below and from above, and cannot be reduced to any other. Relations among junctions are causal, semantic, normative, of power, affective, and symbolic. Emergence means new causal powers that appear at a higher level and are not reducible to the lower level, though they depend on it. Life emerges from chemistry. Mind emerges from neural processes. The self emerges from social interaction. Culture emerges from collective intentionality. Institutions emerge from collective recognition. Meaning emerges from symbolic systems. The representation of God emerges from the crossing of all of them. Emergence is not magic. It means the whole has properties the parts do not have alone. The brain does not think. The person thinks. Neurons do not believe. The person believes.

Constraint limits the space of possibilities without fixing a single outcome. Biology constrains through limits of perception, oxygen, memory, and attention. Physics and chemistry constrain through resources, entropy, and time. The psyche constrains through biases, dissonance, defenses, and fear. The social constrains through norms, sanctions, hierarchies, and belonging. Language constrains through categories, grammar, and available vocabulary. History constrains through path dependence, tradition, and collective trauma. Contingency constrains through the fact that what happened could not have been deduced from laws. Constraint is a frame, not a unique fate.

Strict determination is rare. There is a thesis of physical determination at the micro level, contested by quantum readings, by deterministic chaos, and by the fact that universal determinism is metaphysics, not a laboratory result. There is probabilistic determination in evolution and genetics, where mutation, selection, drift, and contingent events open a space of possibilities. There is structural determination at the social level, through class, institutions, power, habitus, symbolic violence, and path dependence. There is psychic determination through temperament, attachment, trauma, defenses, and biases. No level determines all the others. The error is to believe that biology determines culture, that economy determines religion, that psychology determines sociology, or the reverse. What determines is the interaction of constraints, with emergence and underdetermination. Several outcomes remain possible inside the same frame. Applied to God, biology, the social, and the psyche do not determine the representation. All of them constrain it. The referent, if it exists, is not determined by representation and does not determine representation while bypassing mediation.

The referent does not bypass mediation

If the referent exists, representation does not create it, complete it, feed it, or actualize it. If the referent acts, it acts through created mediations: biology, psyche, the social, culture. There is no raw God at our disposal. Revelation, if it exists, is received through filters. A miracle, if it exists, is an event in a created series, not a breach that skips mediation. The referent is either zero or non-zero, but it is not a component of representation. It is the possible cause of the series, not an item in the series.

That is why the vocabulary of the web applies to God-for-us and breaks when it is applied to the referent. As representation, God mediates functionally between meaning and meaninglessness, life and death, community and individual. It is a represented mediator. The representation of God is a mediation between the subject and the last horizon. It is an emergent junction at the crossing of biology, psyche, the social, and culture. Its emergence does not exist at the level of the neuron, but at the level of the person and of culture. As Actus Purus, God is not a mediator among mediators. God may be called mediator only in a derived sense, as the cause that makes any mediation possible. God is not a process of mediation. God is what makes mediation possible without being mediated in God’s own being. God is not a junction, because a junction is a place in the web, dependent on other junctions. God does not emerge from biology, psyche, or the social. If God emerged, God would be an idol.

Confusion appears when the vocabulary of the web is applied to the referent. Then God is made an item of the world, an idol that feeds on the human filter. Hegel is the name of this slide: God becomes Spirit that comes to know itself through history and depends on recognition. God is not a junction in the web. God is either the vacancy behind it, or the Ground that holds it without being caught in it. If you make God a junction, a mediator among mediators, or an emergent, you have made an idol, which is exactly what social introspection and the anti-idolatrous constraint expose: a God who needs our representation in order to be God.

Theism, other religions, agnosticism, atheism, antitheism

All these stances work in the same field, from the biological to the metaphysical. None is neutral. Each is a mediated representation, an emergent junction, and a place in the field of power that defines the last. The raw data are the same. What differs is what one is allowed to say about the referent.

Each religion is a specific system of mediation. Christianity, Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Taoism, and indigenous religions each have their own cascade of texts, rites, authorities, communities, and practices; their own horizon of meaning concerning the last, salvation, and the human being; their own anti-idolatrous constraint, sometimes explicit, often implicit; their own social junction, with institutions, hierarchies, and power. What unites them is that they are mediated representations of a possible horizon, fragile, historical, able to become collective idols. What separates them is content. Christianity says Incarnation, cross, resurrection. Islam says Qur’an, prophet, tawhid. Buddhism says suffering, cause, cessation, path. Hinduism says Brahman, atman, maya, dharma. The question whether these are different representations of the same referent, different referents, or representations without a referent divides into exclusivism, inclusivism, pluralism, and constructivism. The scheme does not decide. It notes mediation, emergence, junction, and vulnerability to idolatry. The constraint is not that only one tradition is valid. It is that any representation that makes God a consumer of the filter is idolatry, and it applies to Christianity as well.

Agnosticism is the stance that we cannot decide whether the referent exists. It is not atheism and not theism. It is suspension. Phenomenologically it fits the data perfectly, because no representation has privileged access. Ontologically it affirms nothing about the referent, only that we do not know. Socially it can be epistemic humility or avoidance. Psychically it can be tolerance for uncertainty or anxiety before a decision. It can be methodological, in science; metaphysical, as an impossibility in principle; practical, as lived indifference; theistic, as a choice to believe without knowing; atheistic, as a life as if there were none. It is compatible with the anti-idolatrous constraint, yet it can make “I do not know” into a shelter. It remains the epistemic stance most coherent with the scheme, because it neither decides nor closes.

Atheism affirms that God does not exist. It is not a mere absence of belief. It is an affirmation of nonexistence. It can be negative, when it says there is no evidence; positive, when it brings arguments from the problem of evil, the inconsistency of attributes, or divine hiddenness; methodological, in science; existential, as a life without God, whatever the metaphysics. Phenomenologically it is a stance in the field of representations, as mediated as theism. Ontologically it affirms that the referent is zero: a metaphysical decision, not an experimental conclusion. Socially it can be a contestation of religious power or conformity to another group. Psychically it can be release, revolt, indifference, or fear. It cannot be deduced from the data, because the data also fit theism and agnosticism. It is a reading, not a measurement of the referent. It can be more honest than an idolatrous theism. An atheist who refuses a consuming God is closer to the anti-idolatrous constraint than a theist who accepts one.

Antitheism says not only that God does not exist, but that belief in God is a problem and must be fought. It can be epistemic, ethical, political, or militant. It is as mediated as theism. Ontologically it affirms zero and, in addition, the harmfulness of the representation. Socially it can be a contestation of religious power or a new idolatry, in which reason, science, and progress become absolutes. Psychically it can be revolt against religious trauma or a need to control uncertainty. The data show that religion can be harmful and beneficial, depending on setting and power. Ethical justification in the face of abuse does not automatically become an epistemic monopoly. If reason, science, or progress are raised to the last, antitheism becomes a religion without God. An idol is any finite thing raised to last status. The decisive distinction is that antitheism is an ethical and political stance, not only a metaphysical one. “Belief is bad” is normative, not descriptive.

One referent, many referents, zero referent

This is the question that decides everything, and the honest answer is that from inside the scheme one cannot decide. One can map the consequences. The first possibility says that all religions are human answers to the same last Reality, and that diversity is cultural, historical, and psychic. Hick’s pluralism, perennialism, and part of comparative mysticism support it. The arguments are shared structures of the sacred, cross-cultural likenesses of mystical experience, the fact that all speak of a limit and a path, and the fact that diversity is explicable through mediation. The difficulties are real contradictions between a personal God and an impersonal Brahman, the question of who decides what is partial and what is fullness, the risk of a conceptual colonialism that reduces everything to an essence suspiciously liberal-Western, and the fact that “the same referent” is itself a metaphysical claim.

The second possibility says that each religion has its own referent, that there is not one Real, but several last realities. Some contemporary polytheists and some phenomenologists who refuse reduction support it. The argument is that the differences are too large to be only cultural, and that reducing everything to a single referent is an epistemic violence. The difficulty is how we decide which referents exist, how relativism avoids any appraisal, and how a plural last reality does not contradict traditions that speak of One Last.

The third possibility says that all religions are constructions without a referent. Feuerbach, Freud, Marx, Nietzsche, and radical constructivism support it. The arguments are the simplicity of explanation by the likeness of a culture, neural and social correlates, the lack of independent evidence, and the functions of cohesion, control, meaning, and consolation. The difficulties are that the origin of a representation does not decide the referent, that the need for meaning does not cancel meaning, that radical constructivism applies to itself and weakens itself, and that it does not by itself explain the power, persistence, and cross-cultural reach of religious representations.

All three fit the same data. That is the classic underdetermination. Even if all religions have the same function of last horizon, it does not follow that they have the same referent. The function can be universal because it is a structure of consciousness. The referent can be one, many, or zero. To say that all religions are the same is a claim about function. To say that all are different is a claim about representation. Neither is, by itself, a demonstrated claim about the referent. Each stance has an honest form and an idolatrous form. A single referent is honest when it acknowledges mediation and absolutizes no representation. It is idolatrous when it makes the unity of religions into an absolute. Multiple referents are honest when they acknowledge irreducibility. They are idolatrous when one’s own tradition becomes the only valid referent. Zero referent is honest when it is acknowledged as a metaphysical decision. It is idolatrous when it makes reason, science, or progress into an absolute.

The shared mechanism of the stances

After these distinctions a common core can be drawn, not at the level of content, but at the level of structure. All stances work by the recursive mediation of a horizon of meaning, through a cascade of levels. A biological organism produces representational raw material. A psyche organizes it into experience. A social field validates it. A culture systematizes it. A metaphysical stance decides what is said about the referent: non-zero, zero, undecided, multiple. The mechanism is identical in the theist, the atheist, the agnostic, and the antitheist. Content and decision differ. None has privileged access. All are mediated. All can be honest or idolatrous.

The cascade runs both ways and loops back on itself. From below, the physical, chemical, biological, psychic, social, cultural, and metaphysical permit and constrain one another, without complete determination. From above, metaphysics shapes culture, culture the social, the social the psyche, the psyche biology, down to behavior and environment. Downward causality means the whole influences the parts. Culture shapes the brain. The social shapes the psyche. The representation of God shapes the experience of God. The two directions interpenetrate. There is no single point of origin. Representation is produced by the cascade and produces cascade.

Beyond content, all stances share a representational pattern. They posit a last horizon that no longer points onward, whether God, Brahman, Nirvana, Dao, Heaven, humanity, reason, progress, or uncertainty. They recognize a limit of the human condition that the human being cannot cross alone: sin and separation, suffering and ignorance, imbalance, superstition, limits of knowledge. They offer a path: faith and rite, meditation, non-action, reason and education, dialogue and suspension. They have a community that mediates and a set of practices. The pattern is universal. Only the content differs. This is the evidence that religious representation and anti-religious representation are the same kind of phenomenon, even when they deny each other.

The referent, taken as function rather than entity, has shared formal properties: lastness, ineffability, transcendence relative to representation, unquantifiability, underdetermination, independence from representation, no bypassing of mediation, vulnerability to idolatry. These properties do not say what the referent is. They say how it works relative to representation. Content remains irreducible. A personal God who loves is not impersonal Brahman. Nirvana as a state is not the Dao. Zero is not non-zero. One cannot say that all have the same referent without epistemic violence. One can say that all have the same function.

Idolatry appears when function is confused with referent and a finite thing is raised to last status. It can be theistic, when God is an instrument of my power. It can be atheistic, when reason is absolute. It can be agnostic, when “I do not know” becomes an untouchable shelter. It can be antitheistic, when science is salvation. It can be institutional, psychic, or social. The anti-idolatrous constraint is the means by which a stance can examine itself: what am I absolutizing, who benefits, what power do I reproduce.

Why the horizon settles on a finite junction

This confusion has thick causes, not only doctrinal ones. People differ in their tolerance for ambiguity. The need for structure and cognitive closure makes attractive any system that offers a defined horizon, a limit, and a path. It does not matter whether the horizon is God, Reason, Progress, or Uncertainty. The function of reducing ambiguity is the same. Terror management theory starts from the collision between the instinct of self-preservation and the awareness of death. The potential for terror is held by a buffer made of a cultural view of the world and of self-esteem. The need for meaning, certainty, control, and bond extends beyond the pragmatic threshold, as far as a conception of reality that detoxifies death. Any system that offers symbolic immortality, through salvation, progress, science, or community, is psychologically functional. The meaning-maintenance model adds compensatory fluidity: when one meaning is threatened, people affirm other sources. The passage from theism to atheism, from religion to science, from church to nation does not change the mechanism. It changes the junction.

The brain has a default way of making meaning. The default-mode network is active at rest and works narratives about self, world, and last things. Religious experiences depend on its interaction with control and salience networks. Contemplative practices can down-regulate this network and weaken self-consciousness, a phenomenon reported in mysticisms. The theory-of-mind network over-assigns intentionality. The brain is hypersensitive to agency and detects purposes where there may be none. Settling the horizon on a finite junction is eased by this hypersensitivity. Even atheism can personify Reason, Science, or Progress.

Evolved, the need for meaning allowed wide cooperation, trust, and cumulative culture. Groups that shared a common meaning could plan across long spans and sacrifice immediate interests. Meaning is not an epiphenomenon. It is a selected mechanism, biological and cultural, for resilience and cohesion. The finite junction is the focal point that aligns actions, distributes tasks, and mobilizes resources. Without an accessible junction, the horizon remains abstract and fails to move anyone. Historical contingency remains enormous. Any finite junction could have been another. Once settled, it tends to reproduce itself, to institutionalize, to naturalize.

Durkheim saw in religious objects symbols of society, and in sacredness the power society exerts over the member. The function was to preserve solidarity. Luhmann said religion reduces uncertainty and complexity, determines what seems undetermined, and makes accessible what seems inaccessible. Berger and Luckmann showed that knowledge is socially determined and that social reality is produced and communicated, not a brute fact. Geertz read religion as a cultural system of meaning. Turner showed that ritual symbols evoke, channel, and domesticate strong emotions. Ritual fixes meaning in the body, in feeling, in practice. The junction becomes natural, obvious, taken for granted.

The cognitive science of religion describes religious thought as enabled by universal capacities: agency detection, theory of mind applied too widely to the universe, intuitive dualism that makes spirits possible, teleology that explains by purposes. These mechanisms are not specialized for religion. They are specialized for social life. Religion and secular systems of meaning are by-products of them. Tillich named religion ultimate concern: every human being has something that cannot be relativized. Frankl spoke of the will to meaning, which asks for concrete manifestations of a last that exceeds finite intellect. Ellis described absolutizing as holding a belief while suppressing alternatives. The layers converge. The human being is a being that tends to settle the last horizon on a finite junction, because otherwise the horizon remains abstract, unmoving, unlived. The finite junction is not an accidental error. It is the translation, the anchoring, the incarnation. The property applies to theism and atheism alike. What differs is the content and the form of absolutizing.

Manifestations of the ineffable

The ineffable, by definition, does not fit in concept, language, or representation. That is why the human being seeks concrete manifestations, finite junctions that translate the last horizon into something accessible, livable, touchable. These manifestations do not exhaust the ineffable. They incarnate it partly and provisionally. Theophany is the irruption of the last into the world as event, place, and time, encounter rather than idea, with visions, voices, ecstasy, a mountain, a bush, a road. Incarnation radicalizes theophany: the ineffable does not only appear, but becomes a dated, located, mortal human being, a face, a name, a body. Ritual is the craft by which the ineffable is repeated, embodied, collectivized, taken out from under the chance of spontaneous experience and made practice. The symbol is the finite thing that carries last meaning. The text is the ineffable fixed in language, read, recited, memorized, interpreted. Community is the ineffable shared, taken out of solitary experience and made a collective reality. Authority is the ineffable concentrated in a person, with charisma, vocation, teaching, and power. Nature is the ineffable visible in mountain, sea, sky, storm, forest, desert. Art is the ineffable expressed through form. Silence is the ineffable unspoken, worked apophasis, prayer without words. Love is the ineffable lived in the encounter with the other. The limit is the ineffable that shows itself in death, suffering, illness, failure, crisis. The ethical demand is the ineffable that commands, the face of the Other, duty, vocation. None of these manifestations is the moon. All are the finger that points.

The spiral of absolutizing

The reduction of uncertainty makes the junction more absolute because uncertainty is aversive. The brain treats it as a threat. The unknown raises vigilance and stress. People often prefer a certain harm to a prolonged uncertainty. Any junction that reduces uncertainty produces relief. Relief is a reward. Reward creates attachment. The more the junction reduces uncertainty, the stronger the attachment, and the more necessary the junction becomes. It is no longer a means. It becomes the source of safety. The source of safety cannot be relativized without losing safety. Attachment produces investment of time, energy, money, identity, relations. Investment produces sunk cost. The larger the investment, the more painful it is to admit that the junction might be wrong. Dissonance is reduced by intensifying belief, not by leaving. Investment turns into identity. Contesting the junction is felt as an attack on the person. It is no longer a debate about truth. It is a fight for the survival of the self. Identity gathers into community. Community confirms, repeats, celebrates, and sanctions. The junction is no longer an individual choice. It is a norm. Community organizes itself into an institution, with rules, hierarchies, resources, buildings, texts, rites. The institution has its own interest in keeping the junction absolute. It produces power and defends the junction as an end in itself. Repetition creates habitus. Habitus makes the junction seem natural, obvious, taken for granted. Contesting it is no longer an opinion. It is heresy, betrayal, madness. When the junction is natural, it can no longer be relativized. It is the horizon. The absolute cannot be contested without destroying the world. The spiral intensifies. Each cycle makes the junction stronger. The greater the uncertainty around it, the more precious the junction. The more precious it is, the more it is absolutized. The mechanism does not belong to one stance. Theism can absolutize church or scripture, atheism reason and progress, agnosticism uncertainty itself, antitheism science, nationalism the people, Marxism the class, scientism the method.

What a finite system can produce

A finite system, whether organism, psyche, society, or culture, cannot produce the infinite as such. It can produce only the representation of its own limit. The last horizon it produces is its own limit projected as transcendence. The system is conditioned, limited, and reflexive. From these three traits the structural necessity of a horizon appears. Any system of meaning that asks “why?” reaches a limit where the question no longer has an answer inside the system. That limit is the last horizon. It is not a discovery. It is a structural product, the closing condition that makes meaning possible without infinite regress.

The system produces this horizon under several forms that can combine. It produces it as first cause, something that no longer has a cause. It produces it as final aim, something toward which everything tends. It produces it as ground, something that holds everything. It produces it as limit, something beyond which one cannot go. It produces it as meaning, something that makes everything intelligible. A system can hold several forms at once. Christianity, for instance, can read God as creator, as salvation, as sustainer, as judgment, and as Logos. The infinite is still not an object of representation. Every representation is finite. Even the concept of the infinite is a finite concept, a limited idea of what exceeds every limit. The system can produce symbols of the infinite, negations of the finite, analogies, experiences that seem to exceed the finite, junctions that mediate. All of them are finite. They are the finger pointing at the moon, not the moon.

Death, the universe, matter

Death is the natural limit of the reflexive junction. As an organism, the human being does not defeat it. Thermodynamics describes complex systems as dissipative structures that maintain themselves by a flow of energy and do not escape final degradation. Biology describes senescence through many causes, without a single switch that could be turned off. Even organisms with negligible senescence die of hunger, predation, or accident. Neuroscience ties consciousness to the brain and offers no evidence for consciousness after the brain’s death. Research on life extension, cellular reprogramming, cryonics, and the transhumanist hope postpone. They do not defeat. A finite junction cannot cross the limit of the web by its own powers. The human being can delay biologically, accept existentially, transmit symbolically through descendants and work, posit metaphysically a horizon beyond, participate theologically in a referent’s victory. The human being cannot defeat death itself. If the referent exists, death can be read as passage. If not, as end. The difference is metaphysical, not structural.

The observable universe is finite as a horizon of measurement. As a totality, the data fit an infinite extension, a finite topology without edge, and a multiverse. Actual infinity remains philosophically contested. The web can model the universe as elements, relations, places, and junctions, from particles and fields to minds and institutions. Everything in the universe can be an element of the web. The referent, if it exists, is not in the web. The web can be infinite in a mathematical sense or as global possibility, and finite as observable physics, as local semantics, as a human mind. There is no single answer, because there is no single kind of web.

Matter is in the web. It is an element, not a condition of possibility. It is not the referent and it is not God. It can be called eternal only if the web is thought infinite, and even then its eternity remains contingent, not necessary. Scientifically, energy is conserved and degrades entropically. The Big Bang speaks of a beginning of description, not necessarily of an event before time. Cycles and the multiverse remain open. Theologically, the relation between God and matter is filled differently: creation from nothing, emanation, pantheist identity, panentheist encompassing, dualist co-eternity, materialist negation. Structurally, matter is in the web and contingent. The referent, if it exists, is beyond and does not depend on it.

The web, the junction, and idolatry

The web of meaning is the totality of elements, relations, places, and junctions that make significance possible. It is not a collection of things. It is a weave of differences through which something becomes intelligible. Elements are finite: neurons, persons, texts, practices, experiences, institutions, symbols. Relations are the edges: semantic, causal, normative, affective, of power, symbolic, institutional, ritual. Places are locations defined by the pattern of relations: center, periphery, authority, margin, sacred, profane. Junctions are places that concentrate mediation and close the regress of meaning. The physical, biological, psychic, social, cultural, institutional, and metaphysical layers interpenetrate. Each is a web, and the layers influence one another.

The web has no center fixed by nature. The center is a place that different elements can occupy. There is no necessary junction by content. There is the place of a junction, occupiable by any contingent element. The central junction is the place that closes the regress: God, Brahman, Nirvana, Dao, Reason, Progress, Nation, Humanity, or something else. Secondary junctions mediate without occupying the center. The anti-referent, if it is affirmed, is a junction that claims the place and remains in the web. It is not beyond. The human being is a reflexive junction. It does not only occupy a place. It can produce, contest, and question the place. It is the only known junction that can ask about its own place. It is at once junction and maker of junctions.

The referent, if it exists, is beyond the web. It is not an element, a place, or a junction. It is the condition of possibility of the web. It is ineffable, directly inaccessible, unconditioned. No junction can capture it. Any representation of it is a contingent junction. The function of last horizon is structural, emergent, universal in systems of meaning. It closes the regress, makes meaning possible without an infinite chain, and is a condition of action. It cannot be removed without removing meaning. The junction that occupies the function is contingent, historical, replaceable. Idolatry is the confusion of function and junction, the treatment of a finite element as if it were the horizon itself.

The process of making a junction passes through selection, recognition, repetition, concentration, closure, naturalization, and absolutizing. At each stage the element remains the same. The place changes. Exit from idolatry is not the abolition of the horizon. It is the recognition that there is a junction functioning as horizon, the distinction between function and junction, the relativizing of the junction, the opening toward a referent that is neither my junction nor the other’s, dialogue with those who have another junction, and the practice of noticing idolatry when it returns. These steps are a cycle, not a line.

Limits of the frame

The system has a tension between structural neutrality and metaphysical commitment. It claims to describe how junctions work, without deciding what the referent is. The distinction between a referent beyond the web and a representation in the web is already a stance. A radical constructivist will say the distinction is itself a junction. The scheme cannot be neutral toward its own basic distinction. It also has a tension between apophasis and volume. It says we do not speak of the referent cataphatically, then attributes to it that it is beyond, condition, necessary, unconditioned. That is negative cataphasis, not silence. Radical apophasis would be silent. The system speaks.

There is also the tension of self-application. The scheme is a junction. If it claims to describe the very structure of meaning, it claims an access that its own premise forbids. The way out is not to proclaim itself a meta-junction, but to treat it as a discipline of checking, not as an ontology. If “two” is already a category of the web and does not apply to the referent, “one” falls in the same way. Strong anti-dualism turns against strong monism. Of the referent one cannot strictly say one, or two, or zero, except analogically and with withdrawal. Normativity is unjustified if it remains only descriptive. That idolatry is structural does not by itself imply that it must be avoided. Prescription requires an assumed axiology. The word “natural” remains ambiguous unless one specifies whether it is biological, logical, or transcendental. Power, the body, affect, and history are not appendices. They are mediations. The point worth keeping is not the claim to a total system. It is the hygiene. Every statement about the last is mediated. Stopping the regress is a function, not a proof of the source. Who benefits from the junction is a legitimate question. The scheme applies to the scheme.

Conclusion

God-for-us is wholly psychic, social, biological, cultural, and institutional representation. God-in-Godself remains either nonexistent or beyond representation, undecided from inside the web. The human being is a finite reflexive junction, biology become question, a person more than a role. The collective is emergent, constraining, and fragile, a possible witness, an illegitimate master. Biology is substrate, not fate. Death is the limit of the junction, not necessarily of meaning. Matter is in the web and contingent. The web is a model, not an Absolute. The function of horizon is unavoidable. The junction that occupies it is replaceable. Idolatry is the confusion of function and junction. The question “what is God?” cannot be separated from “what is the human being?” and from “what is the society that represents God?”, and it cannot be reduced to them.

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading…

Related

Tags:

Actus Purusagnosticismantitheismapophatic theologyatheismaxiologybeliefbiologycollectivecollective beliefconsciousnessculturedeathemergenceEthicsevidencefaithfilterfinitudefreedomGodhonestyhopehumilityidolatryIncarnationlovemeaningmediationmetaphysicsmoral horizonmysticismneurosciencepowerprayerprofanepsychology of religionreferentrepresentationresponsibilityrevelationsacredsciencesocial idolatrytheismtheologytruthultimate concernunbeliefunderdeterminationvaluesweb of meaning
Unknown's avatar
Author

Andrei Eugen Drăguț

Follow Me
Other Articles
Andrei Eugen Drăguț
Previous

GJ 3090 b orbits its red dwarf backwards and leaves theorists without a giant companion to blame

Impact Hub Bucharest, 25 September 2026: SciLit launch slide between ASUR and SciLit banners; three magenta chairs facing the screen, tote bags on the seats.
Next

The SciLit launch in Bucharest, from a seat in the room

No Comment! Be the first one.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Copyright 2026 — Andrei Eugen Drăguț (AED). All rights reserved.
%d